BrokerExam

Guide

DCPD and the fault determination rules

How direct compensation pays an Ontario driver by degree of fault, and how O. Reg. 668 sets fault in rear-end, lane change, intersection and parking lot claims.

Published 2026-11-07

When another insured car damages your insured’s car in Ontario, your insured claims from their own insurer instead of suing the other driver. That is direct compensation property damage (DCPD), set out in s. 263 of the Insurance Act. Subsection (2) lets the insured recover for damage to the automobile and its contents, and for loss of use, from their own insurer “as though the insured were a third party.” Subsection (3) ties the amount to the insured’s degree of fault “as determined under the fault determination rules,” which are R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 668. The Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) lists both “Direct Compensation for Property Damage (DCPD)” and “Interpreting fault charts” among the auto policy topics in its Level 1 Competency Profile and Blueprint (effective January 2025).

Three conditions and four exceptions

Section 263 (1) needs three things: the automobile or its contents are damaged by the use or operation in Ontario of one or more other automobiles; the damaged automobile is insured under a motor vehicle liability policy from an insurer licensed in Ontario, or one that has filed an undertaking to be bound by the section; and at least one other automobile in the accident is insured the same way.

Four subsections take cases out of it:

  • contents carried for reward (s. 263 (7));
  • damage that occurred before June 22, 1990 (s. 263 (8));
  • both automobiles owned by the same person (s. 263 (9));
  • damage to the insured’s own automobile, or its contents, caused by the insured while driving another automobile (s. 263 (10)).

Where it applies, s. 263 (5) (a) removes the insured’s right of action against anyone involved in the incident, other than their own insurer, for damage to the automobile or its contents or for loss of use. The owner’s form of the Ontario Automobile Policy says the same thing to the policyholder, in OAP 1, Section 6.2: “Section 263 takes away your right to sue the other person for these losses.” It adds a note that the coverage does not apply if the automobile is described in another motor vehicle liability policy, with the example of a borrowed car: the friend claims under the friend’s own policy.

Paying by degree of fault

OAP 1 Section 6.4 sets the payment. The insurer pays the share of the total damages equal to the percentage to which the insured or driver was not at fault, less the DCPD deductible. The deductible is the amount on the Certificate of Automobile Insurance “multiplied by the percentage to which you or the driver of the automobile were not at fault.” It applies to the automobile first and then to contents, and separately to each claim and each insured automobile. The insured cannot sue the at-fault driver to recover it.

In the Act, s. 263 (5.1) lets an insurer agree with an insured to pay only an agreed portion of a claim, or the claim reduced by a set sum, in a class of contract the regulations prescribe, and Reg. 664, s. 8.1 prescribes contracts written on OAP 1 and on Ontario Policy Form 4. Under s. 263 (5.3) such a policy carries the words “This policy contains a partial payment of recovery clause for property damage” on its face.

An example of ours, not RIBO’s and not the policy’s: your insured was turning left at an intersection when a car overtaking to pass hit them, which s. 10 (5) of the fault rules sets at 25 percent fault for your insured. The car needs $8,000 of repairs and the DCPD deductible on the certificate is $300. DCPD pays 75 percent of $8,000, which is $6,000, less 75 percent of $300, which is $225: $5,775. The other $2,225 is your insured’s. OAP 1’s own example of a partly at-fault total loss says the insured “may be entitled to recover part of that amount” under the optional Loss or Damage Coverages in Section 7.

Electing not to recover

Section 263 (2.2) lets an insured elect not to recover under DCPD at all. Reg. 664, s. 5.2 sets how: written confirmation to the insurer, in a form approved by the Chief Executive Officer, naming the automobile the election covers, and revocable by notice to the insurer. The consequence is in s. 263 (2.3). The insured then has no right of action against their insurer for damage to the automobile or its contents or for loss of use, and the insurer “shall not issue or offer collision or upset coverage” to that insured. OAP 1 Section 6.1 repeats both points, and OAP 1 Sections 7.1.1 and 7.1.2 repeat the second.

The general rules in Reg. 668

Under Reg. 668, s. 2, an insurer “shall determine the degree of fault of its insured” by these rules, and the diagrams in the regulation are “merely illustrative.” Four general rules frame every specific one:

  • What does not count. Section 3 sets fault without reference to the circumstances of the incident, including weather, road conditions, visibility or the actions of pedestrians, and without reference to where on the insured’s automobile the point of contact was.
  • More than one rule. Under s. 4 (1), the rule that gives the insured the least fault is deemed the only rule that applies. Under s. 4 (2), when two rules apply to a two-car incident and one makes the insured 100 percent at fault while the other makes them not at fault, the insured is deemed 50 percent at fault.
  • No rule, or too little information. Section 5 sends both cases to the ordinary rules of law.
  • A driving charge. Under s. 20 (2), fault is set by the ordinary rules of law, not the rules, when the driver of automobile “A” is charged with a driving offence and the driver of automobile “B” is wholly or partly at fault under the rules. Section 20 (1) lists the charges, among them impaired driving, refusing a breath sample, an indictable offence related to operating the automobile, and exceeding the speed limit by 16 or more kilometres per hour.

Rules a broker meets often

The regulation calls the cars “A” and “B”. The numbers below are the driver’s share of fault for the incident.

SituationSectionFault
A, stopped or moving forward, is struck from behind by B in the same lane and directions. 6 (2)A 0, B 100
Chain reaction, three cars all moving: A in front, B second, C thirds. 9 (3)A 0 and B 50 for their collision; B 0 and C 100 for theirs
Chain reaction where only C was movings. 9 (4)A and B 0; B 0 and C 100
B changes lanes into A travelling the same directions. 10 (4)A 0, B 100
A turns left at an intersection while B overtakes to pass its. 10 (5)A 25, B 75
Pile-up of three or more cars in adjacent lanes, same directions. 11 (2)50 each, collision by collision
B turns left into the path of As. 12 (5)A 0, B 100
No signs or signals, A enters the intersection firsts. 13 (2)A 0, B 100
All-way stop, both arrive together and stop, A on the rights. 14 (6)A 0, B 100
B fails to obey a traffic signals. 15 (2)A 0, B 100
A leaves a parking space without yielding to B on a feeder lane or thoroughfares. 16 (4)A 100, B 0
A is parked when B strikes its. 17 (1)A 0, B 100
A is backing up, making a U-turn, or a door of A is opened or left opens. 19A 100, B 0

Several rules fall back to 50 percent each when a fact cannot be established: who entered an uncontrolled intersection first (s. 13 (4)), who failed to obey a stop sign (s. 14 (4)), who arrived first at an all-way stop (s. 14 (7)), and whether either driver failed to obey a traffic signal (s. 15 (3)). Where the traffic signals are not working, s. 15 (4) treats the intersection as an all-way stop. In a parking lot, s. 16 (2) treats a thoroughfare as a road, so the road rules apply on it.

Disputes over fault

Section 263 (4) lets an insured sue their own insurer if they are not satisfied that the fault under the rules reflects their actual fault, or with a proposed settlement, and the court decides by the ordinary rules of law. OAP 1 Section 6.7.3 adds appraisal under the Insurance Act for a dispute over the value of the vehicle or contents, repairs, or the amount payable, if the insured asks for it, or if the insurer asks and the insured agrees.

Insurer recovery from others

Section 263 (5) (b) bars the insurer from subrogation or indemnification except as the regulations permit, and Reg. 664 permits three cases, each limited to the share of the loss the fault rules attribute to the other side:

  • the automobile was in the care, custody or control of a business that sells, repairs, maintains, services, stores or parks automobiles (s. 6);
  • the automobile was being towed by a towing business, or by an automobile with a gross vehicle weight over 4,500 kilograms (s. 7);
  • the contents were damaged by more than $20,000, in which case the insurer recovers from the other automobile’s insurer the at-fault share of the loss over $20,000 (s. 8).