Two of the anonymized case studies the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) printed in its newsletter this year ended with the same outcome: a caution from the Complaints Committee. In the February 2026 RIBO Review, a client said their broker did not offer overland water endorsement coverage when the client bought their property policy in 2015. In the April 2026 RIBO Review, a client said their broker did not obtain appropriate insurance for a modified vehicle being added to a spouse’s policy. Each broker was alleged to have breached the same rule, paragraph 3 of the code of conduct in O. Reg. 991, s. 14, and RIBO reports no referral to the Discipline Committee in either.
RIBO introduces the series as based on “anonymized situations about brokers and brokerages who were alleged to have breached” the Act, the by-laws, the regulations and other rules, and who became the subjects of investigations.
The committee
Under s. 12 (1) of the Registered Insurance Brokers Act, the Council must establish one or more Complaints Committees, beside a Qualification and Registration Committee and a Discipline Committee. Section 15 sets its make-up: as many persons as Council decides, with at least one who is not a member of RIBO and who was appointed to Council or to the panel of lay persons by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. Nobody on the Discipline Committee may sit on a Complaints Committee, and a majority is a quorum. RIBO’s Complaints and Discipline Process page describes the committee as three members, two licensees and one public member appointed by the Government of Ontario, who review the evidence an investigation collects.
Section 16 gives it its work. It considers and investigates complaints about any member’s conduct or actions. Before it can refer a matter to the Discipline Committee, a written complaint must have been filed with the Manager, the member must have been notified and given at least two weeks to answer in writing, and the committee must have examined, or made every reasonable effort to examine, the records and documents relating to the complaint. Then, under s. 16 (2), it may:
- direct that the matter be referred, in whole or in part, to the Discipline Committee;
- direct that it not be referred;
- take such action as it considers appropriate in the circumstances and that is not inconsistent with the Act, the regulations or the by-laws.
A caution, as RIBO describes it
The word caution does not appear in the Act. It comes from RIBO’s process page, which lists among the committee’s possible outcomes taking “remedial action against the licensee by issuing a caution, giving the licensee advice, directing them to take one or more courses” or sending the case back for further investigation, alongside the other two: not referring the case, and referring it to the Discipline Committee.
The same page says what follows from each. The Complaints Committee writes a decision for every case; the licensee receives a copy and the complainant is told the outcome in writing. A case that is not referred, where the committee takes remedial action, does not become part of the licensee’s discipline history and is not published, but it does become part of the licensee’s regulatory history with RIBO. A referral starts the discipline process, in which the Discipline Committee decides whether the allegations are proven and the penalty, and its decisions are public and become part of the licensee’s discipline history.
A caution comes from the Complaints Committee, not from a Discipline Committee hearing. RIBO’s case studies describe each broker as “alleged” to have committed misconduct, and neither reports a finding that the allegation was proven.
February: the overland water endorsement
RIBO’s account: a client alleged that Principal Broker “Sheila” did not offer Overland Water Endorsement (OWE) coverage when the client bought their property policy in 2015. In 2024 the client’s basement was damaged by water, and the insurer denied the claim because the policy had no OWE coverage. In the investigation, Sheila said she did not believe OWE coverage was available in 2015 and could not confirm whether it had been offered or mentioned.
The Complaints Committee cautioned Sheila. RIBO reports three statements with the caution: that she had an obligation to communicate all coverages available under the policies offered and to make sure the insured knew of potential coverage gaps; that she should improve the internal quoting process so all gaps are addressed; and that the brokerage should improve its communication so clients are shown all possible coverage options and pricing.
The three kinds of water this case turns on are read through one published home policy in Water damage, sewer backup and overland water.
April: the modified vehicle
RIBO’s account: a client alleged that Principal Broker “Armand” did not obtain appropriate vehicle insurance when a vehicle was to be added to the client’s spouse’s policy. The client had sent the registration and other documents and told the broker about modifications to the vehicle, with instructions to forward the information to the insurer. A tree later fell on the vehicle. The insurer, which had not known of the modifications until the claim, offered a settlement based on an unmodified vehicle.
This time the Complaints Committee issued the caution to the brokerage and placed a letter of caution in the brokerage file. RIBO gives two reasons. The vehicle was being added to the spouse’s policy, no application was made, and no declaration by the insured was made or requested at the time. And after the incident the brokerage put new procedures in place, which the committee found sufficient to satisfy the standard of care going forward.
The rule in both
Paragraph 3 of the code of conduct requires a member to serve the client “in a conscientious, diligent and efficient manner” and to provide service at least equal to what members would generally expect of a member in a like situation. RIBO’s Code of Conduct Handbook measures it against what an ordinarily prudent and competent broker would do in the same situation. Both Reviews point readers to paragraph 3 and to pages 13 and 14 of that handbook, and each closes with a reminder of expectations. In February: review and explain with clients what is and is not covered before binding, so there are no coverage gaps, and give clients all the coverage options for their needs. In April: collect and clarify all necessary client information and provide it to the insurer.