BrokerExam

Case note

The PC Financial decision: postal code lead filters

From at least 2014 to April 2022, an auto brokerage filtered aggregator leads by postal code area. A Take-All-Comers breach, a guilty plea and a $50,000 fine.

Published
2026-11-06

From at least 2014 until April 12, 2022, an Ontario auto insurance brokerage kept consumers in some postal code areas from getting its quotes. PC Financial Insurance Brokers Inc. bought consumer leads from insurance comparison websites and filtered them by the first segment of the postal code. On October 22, 2026 it pleaded guilty before a panel of the Discipline Committee of the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) to misconduct for breaching the Take-All-Comers rule, and was reprimanded and fined $50,000. The decision is PC Financial Insurance Brokers Inc., 2026 ONRIBODC 14 (CanLII), and RIBO’s published decisions page carries the same text as a PDF.

The decision’s heading names the firm PC Financial Insurance Brokers Inc.; the agreed statement of facts spells it PC Financial Insurance Broker Inc. and calls it “PC Broker”.

The brokerage

The agreed facts describe an automobile insurance brokerage that operated from about 2009 and did not directly employ any licensed brokers or sell insurance directly. It retained HPC Insurance Services, “an entity controlled by HUB”, to perform its brokerage services. The agreed facts record that it ceased broker operations in March 2026 and surrendered its brokerage licence effective April 30, 2026, months before the hearing (paragraph [9], facts 1 and 2). RIBO first received information about its quoting practices from the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) beginning in about March 2023 (fact 3).

What the filters did

The brokerage quoted auto insurance mainly through aggregator websites and an internal quoting platform run for it by a third-party service provider. Each request for a quote on an aggregator site is a lead, and the brokerage bought a finite number of leads for a fee, choosing the ones it concluded would most likely convert into a sale (facts 4 to 6).

The filters worked on Forward Sortation Areas, “specific geographic areas indicated by the first segment of a postal code.” Their effect was to exclude prospective consumers in specified areas from receiving its quotations through the aggregator sites and its own platform (fact 7). Some filtering was requested on insurer-related considerations, including insurer concerns about loss ratios or profitability in particular areas. Some was the brokerage’s own business choice, on lead-conversion rates and marketing efficiency (fact 8). It ran through instructions to the aggregator sites and the configuration of the quoting platform (fact 9).

Why it was a Take-All-Comers breach

Throughout the period, insurers writing auto insurance in Ontario were required to file their underwriting rules with FSRA. On a request for an auto quote, the agreed facts say the Take-All-Comers rule and the guidance around it required two things: the lowest rate available from any insurer the broker is affiliated with, and no declining, restricting or differentiating access except under underwriting rules filed with and approved by FSRA (facts 10 and 11). The postal code filters “did not and could not form part of the insurers’ approved underwriting rules,” and applying them may have meant consumers whose leads were not pursued did not receive the lowest rate available from an affiliated insurer (fact 12). The panel noted that the evidence did not quantify how many consumers were affected (paragraph [21]).

The charge ran through the brokers’ code of conduct. O. Reg. 991, s. 14, paragraph 10, requires a member to make its services “available to the public in an efficient and convenient manner which will command respect and confidence.” The brokerage admitted it had not, and that the failure to comply with the Take-All-Comers rule was misconduct under paragraph 8 of s. 15 (1), failing to carry on business consistently with the code (fact 20, paragraph [6]). RIBO withdrew, on consent, the other allegations: s. 14, paragraph 1, and s. 15 (1), paragraphs 1 and 9 (paragraphs [7] and [8]).

The panel called the rule “a significant consumer protection and market conduct requirement in Ontario auto insurance,” one that limits how far insurers and intermediaries can steer away from business they find unattractive when the applicant meets the insurer’s approved underwriting rules. Because auto insurance is mandatory in Ontario, it said, practices that restrict who gets a quote can undermine both access to coverage and confidence in the brokerage system (paragraphs [19] and [20]).

Two rounds of guidance

On February 28, 2020, RIBO issued guidance to principal brokers reminding them of their Insurance Act obligations and the Take-All-Comers rule. The brokerage did not change or stop the filtering (facts 13 and 14). After FSRA issued further guidance on November 15, 2021 clarifying how the rule applies, it took immediate steps to review the filtering. The filters came out of its internal quoting system by or around February 28, 2022, but kept running on one aggregator site, LowestRates.ca, until April 12, 2022 (facts 15 to 18). November 15, 2021 is also the effective date of FSRA’s Take-All-Comers guidance, AU0135INT, which says a broker using an aggregator or a technology provider keeps full responsibility for making sure its business does not breach the rule.

What a broker discloses and when covers the Take-All-Comers side of the quote, and the 2024-2025 spot check findings show RIBO still finding Take-All-Comers gaps in brokerage files.

The penalty

The parties filed a joint submission, and the panel accepted it under the high bar for rejecting one set in R. v. Anthony-Cook and applied to Ontario disciplinary bodies in Bradley v. Ontario College of Teachers (paragraph [17]). The order, effective October 22, 2026, is a reprimand and a $50,000 fine payable to the Minister of Finance within 30 days (paragraph [14]). The panel noted that the maximum fine for a member that is not an individual is $100,000 (paragraph [27]); s. 22 of O. Reg. 991 sets $25,000 for an individual.

The panel was “deeply concerned” with the length of the conduct and treated it, with the failure to act on RIBO’s 2020 guidance, as aggravating (paragraphs [21] to [24]). More than 16 years with no other RIBO investigation and no discipline was argued as mitigating; the panel did not accept that, given how long the misconduct ran, and treated the clean record as neutral (paragraph [25]). Full cooperation, the admissions in the agreed facts and settling without a contested hearing counted in the brokerage’s favour (paragraph [26]). Because it had stopped operating and given up its licence, the panel gave rehabilitation and specific deterrence less weight and general deterrence more (paragraph [29]).